Eight people went on trial in France on Monday, charged with contributing to the climate of hatred that led to an 18-year-old Islamist radical of Chechen origin beheading teacher Samuel Paty outside Paris in 2020.
Seven men and one woman are appearing in court in the trial, set to last until December, over the murder of 47-year-old Paty, a teacher of history and geography.
The trial – to run until December 20 – began with the defendants and dozens of witnesses confirming their identity.
Perpetrator Abdoullakh Anzorov, who had requested asylum in France, was killed by police shortly after he murdered Paty near the latter’s school in Conflans-Sainte-Honorine west of Paris.
The teacher, who had shown his class cartoons of the Islamic Prophet Mohammed from the satirical magazine Charlie Hebdo, is regarded as a free speech hero by the French authorities.
This court sketch made and published on November 4, 2024, shows (L-R) defendants Abdelhakim Sefrioui, Louqmane Ingar, Azim Epsirkhanov, Priscilla Mangel and Yusuf Cinar sitting during the trial of eight adults charged with contributing to the climate of hatred that led to an 18-year-old Islamist radical in the 2020 beheading teacher Samuel Paty
History and geography teacher Samuel Paty, 47, was decapitated outside a school near Paris after receiving death threats for showing cartoons of the Prophet Mohammed in a lesson
General view of the courthouse on the Ile de la Cite on the first day of the trial of eight people accused of involvement in the beheading of French history teacher Samuel Paty by a suspected Islamist in 2020 in an attack outside his school in the Paris suburb of Conflans-Sainte-Honorine
Six defendants, three of whom are under judicial supervision, are being tried for participation in a criminal terrorist act, which is punishable by 30 years in jail.
They will not be cross-examined on their alleged involvement in the killing until November 20.
They include Brahim Chnina, a 52-year-old Moroccan.
He is the father of a schoolgirl, then aged 13, who falsely claimed that Paty had asked Muslim students to leave his classroom before showing caricatures of the prophet Mohammed.
She was not in the classroom at the time.
Also on trial is Abdelhakim Sefrioui, a 65-year-old Franco-Moroccan Islamist activist.
He and Chnina spread the teenager’s lies on social networks with the aim, according to the prosecution, of ‘designating a target’, ‘provoking a feeling of hatred’ and ‘thus preparing several crimes’.
Both men have been in pre-trial detention for the past four years.
Between October 9 and 13, Chnina spoke to Anzorov nine times by telephone after he published videos criticising Paty, the investigation showed.
Sefrioui posted a video criticising what he considered to be Islamophobia in France and describing Paty as a ‘teaching thug’, but told investigators he was only seeking ‘administrative sanctions’.
People look at flowers layed outside the Bois d’Aulne secondary school in homage to slain history teacher Samuel Paty, who was beheaded by an attacker for showing pupils cartoons of the Prophet Mohammed in his civics class, on October 19, 2020, in Conflans-Sainte-Honorine, northwest of Paris. Eight people aged 22 to 65 are appearing before the special assize court in Paris starting on November 4, 2024
Relatives and colleagues hold a picture of Samuel Paty
French lawyer for the French Association of Victims of Terrorism (AFVT) Antoine Casubolo Ferro answers journalists as he arrives for the trial of eight adults for the murder of teacher Samuel Paty
Two young friends of the attacker are facing even graver charges of ‘complicity in terrorist murder’, a crime punishable by life imprisonment.
Naim Boudaoud, 22, and Azim Epsirkhanov, 23, a Russian of Chechen origin, are accused of having accompanied Anzorov to a knife shop in the northern city of Rouen the day before the attack.
‘Nearly three years of investigation have never managed to establish that Naim Boudaoud had any knowledge of the attacker’s criminal plans,’ his lawyers Adel Fares and Hiba Rizkallah told AFP.
Boudaoud is accused of accompanying Anzorov to buy two replica guns and steel pellets the day of the attack.
Epsirkhanov admitted he had received 800 euros from Anzorov to find him a real gun but had not succeeded.
Paty had used the Charlie Hebdo magazine as part of an ethics class to discuss free speech laws in France, where blasphemy is legal and cartoons mocking religious figures have a long history.
His killing took place just weeks after Charlie Hebdo republished the Prophet Mohammed cartoons.
After the magazine used the images in 2015, Islamist gunmen stormed its offices, killing 12 people.
Four other defendants interacted with Anzorov online.
Yusuf Cinar, a 22-year-old Turkish national, shared a jihadist Snapchat account with him, that later published images of Paty’s killing.
Ismail Gamaev, a 22-year-old Russian of Chechen origin with refugee status, and Louqmane Ingar, also 22, exchanged jihadist content on a Snapchat group with Anzorov. The first posted an image of Paty’s head with smiley faces after the killing.
The only woman on trial is 36-year-old Priscilla Mangel, a Muslim convert who conversed with Paty’s killer on X, describing the teacher’s class as ‘an example of the war waged by (France’s) Republican institutions against Muslims’.
Thibault de Montbrial and Pauline Ragot, lawyers for Mickaelle Paty, one of the sisters of the murdered teacher, said his killing had highlighted the ‘depth of Islamist infiltration in France’.
The trial should ‘allow our society to become aware of a mortal peril’, they added.
Six former secondary school pupils were sentenced in December 2023 to terms ranging from 14 months suspended to six months in prison, following a closed-door trial before the juvenile court. Those sentenced to prison, however, will not serve jail time.
Chnina’s daughter was sentenced to 18 months of probation after being convicted of slander.
The girl, still a minor, is to speak in court on November 26.
