Brazil’s proposal
The issue is set to come to a head next week, as the Convention on International Trade in Endangered Species of Wild Fauna and Flora (CITES) holds its 20th meeting.
Heightened restrictions on brazilwood are scheduled to be raised for a vote at the conference.
Since 1998, the International Union for Conservation of Nature (IUCN) has classified the tree as endangered.
But a proposal authored by the Brazilian government would increase CITES protections for brazilwood, placing it in the highest tier for trade restrictions.
CITES regulates the international trade of endangered species, and it classifies animals and plants in three appendices.
The third is the least restrictive: If a species is endangered in a given country, then export permits are required from that country.
The Appendix II has tighter standards: Export permits are required from wherever the species is extracted. Most endangered species, including brazilwood, fall into this category.
But Brazil hopes to bump brazilwood up to appendix one, a category for species faced with extinction.
Trade of plants and animals in that appendix is largely banned, except for non-commercial use. But even in that case, both import and export licences are required.
In its proposal, Brazil argues the upgraded restrictions are necessary to fight the plant’s extinction.
Only about 10,000 adult brazilwood trees remain. The population has shrunk by 84 percent over the last three generations, and illegal logging has played a dominant role in that decline, according to the proposal.
“Selective extraction of Brazilwood is still active, both inside and outside protected areas,” the proposal explains.
“In all cases recently detected, the destination of these woods is the bow-making industry for musical instruments.”
It adds that “520 years of intense exploitation” have led to the “complete elimination of the species in several regions”.
One operation launched by Brazilian police in October 2018 resulted in 45 companies and bowmakers being fined.
Nearly 292,000 bows and blanks — the unfinished blocks of wood destined to become bows — were seized.
Another investigation, between 2021 and 2022, led police to conclude that an estimated $46m in profits had come from the illegal brazilwood trade.
“The majority of bows and bow blanks sold by Brazilian companies over the past 25 years probably originated from illegal sources,” Brazil wrote in its proposal.
