A member of the California Assembly representing part of Los Angeles has proposed a bill that aims to reduce vigilantism but that critics say would criminalize self-defense.
Assemblymember Rick Chavez Zbur (D-Los Angeles) proposed Assembly Bill 1333, which “would eliminate certain circumstances under which homicide is justifiable, including, among others, in defense of a habitation or property,” CalMatters explains.
“The bill would additionally clarify circumstances in which homicide is not justifiable, including, among others, when a person uses more force than necessary to defend against a danger,” the outlet added.
Deadly force wouldn’t be considered necessary when the shooter could have safely retreated, during cases of mutual combat or when the shooter “knowingly provoked a person,” CalMatters detailed.
“What this bill is focused on is someone who goes out in public, picks a fight — and when the victim responds — they shoot them and claim self-defense,” Zbur told CalMatters.
Republicans, however, say the bill would take away people’s right to self-defense.
“We have situations where police have to react in the moment, and those are trained individuals,” said Assemblymember David Tangipa of Fresno. “Now we’re asking people who are untrained to make decisions that could cost them their lives. … It doesn’t matter the (bill’s) intentions, it’s the implications at the end of the road.”
The bill could be heard in committee later this month.
